A couple interesting things from Arjun Divecha in this week’s Barron’s. First, on the Chindia “misperception” –
“India has benefited hugely from this misperception of “Chindia.” By linking China and India together, people think that India is in the same league as China when, in fact, it is not. Let me give you a few numbers: In global zinc consumption, China consumed 29%, India consumed 3.8%; aluminum, China consumed 25%, India consumed 2.6%; oil, China consumed 9% of global oil, and India consumed 3% of global oil. These countries are not compatible. They are not even in the same league. India has got a whole lot of capital that it would not have gotten if people had thought of it separately. India is where China was 15 years ago in terms of per capita consumption. It is a great growth story, but equating it with China has meant a lot of global liquidity has flowed to it and helped India’s performance. It has made Indian stocks quite expensive, and that’s why it is our least favorite country. The economic story is terrific, the valuation story is not.”
Second, on the possibility (ha! why hedge?) of a bubble in China:
“China we don’t like, either. Although, I want to caution you on China because China could be in the beginning stages of a fairly large bubble. I’m not predicting it. I’m just saying it’s a possibility. There is a huge flood of money coming into the country as exports lead to massive amounts of capital inflows…so large the central government has not been able to sterilize them … The money supply has been growing at the 15% to 17%, about in line with GDP growth. But now it has suddenly stepped up to 25% or 30%, and in the last few months inflation has gone up to 6.9% in China.
That in and of itself could be a problem, but that is not what I’m focused on. I am focused on short-term interest rates at 3½%. If you are a saver in China, you are getting 3½% from the bank while inflation is at 6.9%. You can’t take money out of the country. So what are your options? Real estate and the stock market. That is why the stock market has gone up so much this year. This trend isn’t changing any time in a hurry.”
Related: Losing Less Money on Chinese Bank Deposits — Yippee!
(This is my last issue of Barron’s since I’ve canceled both it and wsj.com anticipating Rupert’s making them both free soon.)
time saved
time saved