I thought it would be good to update and review one of the box trades from last week, and talk about various ways to manage the fear and greed of this open trade. You’ll recall my post last Sunday with this box pick:
Short MAN below 64.10
Protective Stop above 65.13
Target #1: 54.44 to 55.20
Target #2: 51.86 to 52.58
Target #3: 44.22 to 44.83
(IF YOU’D LIKE TO RECEIVE THESE DAILY TRADING IDEAS, PLEASE EMAIL ME TO JOIN THE LIST.)
A short entry should have been taken last Monday below 64.10 and a protective stop instantly put in place above 65.13. Assuming that you were risking around $500 on the trade, you would have shorted 500 shares.
On Tuesday the stock traded lower and closed at 62.13, which was close to 2x your initial risk. If you were the skittish type, you’d move your protective stop to breakeven by this point. On Wednesday MAN closed lower at 60.95, almost exactly 3x your initial risk. On Thursday the stock closed at 60.38 and on Friday at 59.45, over 4x your initial risk.
The highest target the box is looking for is 55.20, which is over 7% below Friday’s close (quite a drop).
An open short of 500 shares would be sitting on around $2300 of gains here, and you wouldn’t want to give that all up if price reverses and goes back up. I’m open to suggestions about what to do here (please leave a comment), but here’s one idea:
I think it might be smart to lock in around $500 in gains by covering 100 shares here and moving the protective stop on the remaining 400 shares down to around breakeven at $64 (if you hadn’t done that already). You can wait patiently for 55.20 with the knowledge that you took around $500 out and won’t get hurt on the remaining 400 shares if price reverses and trades back up through $64.
Letting it ride (greed) and intelligent stop management (fear) is an art that I certainly have never mastered.
What do you guys think?
time saved
time saved