I found this nice list of college selectivity and thought I’d re-present it by state. You should NOT consider attending any college below these top two tiers, unless it is your state university and cheap. There are fewer than 100 “selective” colleges in the entire United States.
First Tier:
California:
California Institute of Technology
Claremont McKenna College
Harvey Mudd College
Pomona College
Stanford University
University of Southern California
Connecticut:
Yale University
Illinois:
Northwestern University
University of Chicago
Maine:
Bowdoin College
Colby College
Maryland:
Johns Hopkins University
Massachusetts:
Amherst College
Harvard University
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Tufts University
Williams College
Minnesota:
Carleton College
Missouri:
Washington University
New Hampshire:
Dartmouth College
New Jersey:
Princeton University
New York:
Barnard College (womens’ college)
Columbia University
Cornell University
North Carolina:
Duke University
Pennsylvania:
Swarthmore College
University of Pennsylvania
Rhode Island:
Brown University
Tennessee:
Vanderbilt University
Texas:
Rice University
Washington, DC:
Georgetown University
Second Tier:
California:
Scripps College (womens’ college)
University of California, Berkeley
University of California, Los Angeles
Colorado:
Colorado College
Connecticut:
Trinity College
Wesleyan University
Florida:
University of Miami
Georgia:
Emory University
Georgia Institute of Technology
Indiana:
University of Notre Dame
Iowa:
Grinnell College
Louisiana:
Tulane University
Maine:
Bates College
Massachusetts:
Boston College
Boston University
Brandeis University
Northeastern University
Smith College (womens’ college)
Wellesley College (womens’ college)
Michigan:
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
New York:
Colgate University
Cooper Union
Hamilton College
New York University
University of Rochester
Vassar College
North Carolina:
Davidson College
Wake Forest University
Ohio:
Case Western Reserve University
Oregon:
Reed College
Pennsylvania:
Bucknell University
Carnegie Mellon University
Haverford College
Lehigh University
Villanova University
Texas:
Trinity University
Vermont:
Middlebury College
Virginia:
University of Richmond
University of Virginia
Washington and Lee University