Episode 113 ... Benjamin Small (60:02)
Interesting episode ... I know a bit more about Bitcoin now.
- Got Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering in 2006
- Wall street firms started hiring people like him to automate things
- At UBS in spring 2006
- "Junior Quantitative Researcher"
- Prop trading allowed before Volcker Rule
- UBS had huge retail market making operation
- Worked on whether to internalize retail order flow or send it to the Street
- Algorithm they design makes the decision
- UBS, Citadel, KCG biggest buyers of order flow
- They want exclusive access to retail order flow
- Most retail orders are market order or marketable orders
- Any order that's willing to cross the bid ask spread has value
- Non-marketable limit orders must be routed to an exchange
- Brokers pick an exchange where rebates highest
- Beginning 10-15 years ago, desks got more aggressive about maximizing profitability
- Equity options orders can't be internalized (illegal)
- Trading desks are profitable, so are retail investors getting screwed by them? Tricky question
- Off-exchange volume is ~30% of total volume
- Worked at Citadel, then Credit Suisse
- Built statistical models to improve prop trading desk algorithms for eight years in all
- Must constantly tweak, fine-tune models used by desk
- Monitoring the algorithms in real time to improve things
- Latency is a huge issue in US equity markets
- Have to optimize computer code so it's fastest, competitive edge
- Memory versus disk versus cache
- Worked at IEX, head of quantitative research for one year
- IEX had ambitions to become an exchange (now it is one)
- One of the inventors of the "Discretionary Peg" order
- Tries to predict on client's behalf to switch between inside peg and midpoint peg
- Works at Gemini currently, head of market structure
- Market structure an interesting combination of microeconomics, statistics, and computer science
- Most Bitcoin exchanges have central limit order book
- Winklevoss twins founded Gemini a few years ago
- Received licensing to trade Bitcoin from New York State Department of Financial Services ~15 months ago
- Gemini a fully regulated, licensed Bitcoin exchange
- Traditional financial services players could be comfortable with Bitcoin on Gemini
- Licensing important because US heavily regulates financial services
- Risk and compliance concerns put to rest
- Need to make an on-ramp for institutional money into Bitcoin
- Need to normalize Bitcoin, just another asset, not a crazy crypto-currency
- Evidence that people are seeing Bitcoin as a virtual store of value, not just a speculative thing
- More institutions are getting involved in Bitcoin
- Majority of Bitcoin trading is by professional Bitcoin market makers
- Only 20-25% of stock trading is retail
- Bitcoin not too tightly correlated with other asset classes, useful for portfolio managers
- Choice of exchange and wallet providers is all important ... your account could be hacked [or Mt. Gox'd]
- Many Bitcoin exchanges and wallet providers are not vigilant about security
- Can manage your own Bitcoin wallet but if you lose the key, it's lost
- Bitcoin trading primitive, only $15BB market cap
- Most sophisticated market makers don't want to deal with Bitcoin because it's too small
- Think of trading SPY by comparison -- tons of market makers, penny spread, hundreds of millions of notional at both bid and offer at any time
- Any aribtrage opportunities in Bitcoin?
- Arbitrage across exchanges worldwide ... liquidity, credit risk different by exchange
- Statistical arbitrage a profitable strategy by itself
- HFT haven't entered Bitcoin ecosystem ... yet
- Lots of scams and ponzi schemes in crypto-currencies, just like penny stocks
- Why is Bitcoin big in China? Avoiding capital controls and Chinese are natural speculators (gamblers)
- There are hundreds of other crypto-currencies, alt-coins
- Bitcoin is only five years old, but it's the "core concept"
- Ethereum network added a lot of new ideas, help ecosystem evolve, "Ether" is the token
- Ether has "smart contracts" -- like a derivative contract but enshrined in computer code, not law
- Ether faster than Bitcoin when it comes to settling transactions
- Founder of Ethereum is a young Russian kid from east Brooklyn
- Bitcoin has first-mover advantage
- 10 or 20 years from now, could be a much better idea than Bitcoin
- Gemini has anti-money-laundering controls
- Bitcoin is no scam
- Any alt-coin that doesn't have an adequate market cap should be avoided
- Look at the source code, all alt-coins are open source, do background research
- Lots of oddball alt-coins based on weird ideas
- Big laboratory for experimentation
- "Shitcoin"
- 4PM auction at Gemini, match buyers and sellers to get a solid price for the asset, one price
- Walrasian equilibrium is the algo they use
- Gemini exchange broadcasts forecasted auction price starting at 3:50 PM
- Bitcoin will eventually take its place among commodities like gold and oil (he predicts)
- Bitcoin has mathematically defined supply, so should become stable store of value [he says hopefully]
- Transactions take 30 minutes to clear on the blockchain -- slow!
- In future, with instant transfer of value, Bitcoin accepted at point of sale is a possibility
- We never touch paper currency anymore, all credit cards and (stored credit cards at) Amazon now
- Banks already have full control of your money, no need to be paranoid about it
- www.gemini.com
- Not on Twitter