Notes for Chat with Traders, Episodes 149 and 150

Added on by C. Maoxian.

Episodes 149 & 150 ... Aaron Brown (59:21, 64:19)

Interesting guy ... clearly not a conventional thinker or person ... I enjoyed it.

  • At AQR ($200 billion quant fund) for a decade
  • Didn't like the commute to AQR
  • Liked reading numbers in back of newspaper (sports and financial statistics) as a boy
  • Read Thorp's Beat the Dealer, fascinated by it
  • Grew up in the western US in the 1960s (Seattle)
  • Became obsessed with money around age 14 in the early 1970s
  • People who lost their jobs in the neighborhood disappeared; it was creepy
  • Very shy kid, 14 years old, tried to play poker to make money, and it worked
  • Went to Harvard, took a lot of math and statistics, graduate courses only, Harrison White signed off on it
  • Harvard grad students are dumber than Harvard undergrads, classes more interesting at grad level
  • Becoming better known as pro poker player ... also did a lot of sports betting
  • It's hard to scale up when you win at poker
  • Your unconscious brain wins poker at the highest levels, not understanding the numbers
  • Have to enlist your unconscious brain to win at high levels of poker
  • Don't let fear and greed drown out the quiet voices in your brain
  • Good traders use their unconscious brain to make good trades
  • Sleep deprivation stimulates a certain kind of learning
  • You need to know yourself, what motivates you
  • Your conscious brain isn't consulted when you make decisions, you just make up excuses after the fact
  • 1978-79, people didn't really know how to trade options
  • If you could do option math in your head, you could make money
  • Floor trading options you can pick up crumbs, but you can't scale
  • They were worried about the speed of sound in a 20 foot radius around options specialist post [not the speed of light as in the HFT age, a funny comment]
  • You had to physically be in the pit, and the trades were small time, no big lots
  • Couldn't get rich betting sports games, but you could get rich running a bookie operation
  • Entered Ph.D. program in finance at U. of Chicago 
  • Managed billion dollar bond fund in the 1980s
  • Head of mortgage securities
  • Crash of 1987 hurt everyone
  • Became a professor for a time
  • Went to work for JP Morgan
  • It's easy to make money, but hard to keep it
  • Invented the term "risk management" (outside of the insurance industry), didn't mean "risk minimization"
  • Front office risk manager decides how much traders can bet
  • CEO talks to middle office risk manager who talks to the front office risk manager who talks to the traders
  • Started at AQR in May 2007 and crisis hit in August 2007
  • Cut risk in late July 2007 just by chance
  • Losing a worst-case loss for a year every day, day after day, for three days
  • Cliff Asness called the bottom of it, whether by chance or not, no one knows [Cliff is now a billionaire]
  • Quant equity crisis of 2007, everyone forgot about it after the 2008 crisis hit
  • Featured in Scott Patterson's book, The Quants
  • 3000 longs and 3000 shorts simultaneously, make tiny gains with massive leverage, that's the idea
  • Quant equity funds all had overlapping positions, this was part of the problem
  • Funds don't have to report their short positions, only longs
  • Brokers can tell you what is Hard To Borrow
  • Quants are engineers, logical ... learn from mistakes
  • Quants don't like to change bet size just because of losses, hate drawdown control policies
  • Down 10% in a month, whether through losses or redemptions, clients can terminate contracts
  • Let investors out who want to get out, you don't want them in your fund anyway
  • You never want to be in a trade where the risk is managing you
  • All words for risk have some opinion attached to it (either positive or negative)
  • Traders have a very different idea about risk
  • Risk is something we exploit, it's like energy, and we respect it
  • Most people like predictability, but some people are more spontaneous
  • Gamblers and thrill seekers trade with no edge
  • The goal of trading is making money, that's your job, nothing else matters
  • Most people don't know why they do what they do
  • Most people who try to trade are pursuing some silly illusion
  • The best traders do it because they can't imagine doing anything else
  • You want to start risk taking when you're young, can't do it when there are "adult stakes"
  • The best traders are really bad about explaining how they manage risk
  • Traders who try to swing big to make up for past losses, it's a disaster
  • But you have to be willing to make big bets even after a series of losses
  • How far do things have to go against you before you know that you're wrong?
  • Traders internalize two ideas: they might be right and they might be wrong
  • How much does it make if you're right, how much does it lose if you're wrong?
  • Only need two scenarios in your mind for any trade
  • You equally weight both scenarios in your mind
  • How much are you willing to lose when you're wrong? Must decide this first
  • Most traders leave too much money on the table most of the time
  • Most traders spend 80% of pre-trade strategy about capping the downside
  • They should spend 80% of the time figuring out what they're going to do if they're right
  • How do you exit a trade when you're right? This is the key question
  • Some people want to win a lot of pots (at poker) instead of winning a big pot
  • You have to know who you are ... do you prefer scalping (winning lots of pots) or holding for a larger gain (winning an occasional big pot)?
  • You should know your profit ratio: average win on winning trades divided by the average loss on losing trades
  • Your win ratio is going to be whatever it is... think harder about your profit ratio
  • Don't try to guess what will happen, just prepare for what might happen
  • Risk avoidance mistake: start small and then get bigger (you should reverse this)
  • Plan for success! Pick a size and stick with it
  • Emotional decision making means reckless decisions
  • Focus on median outcomes (not the average outcome) ... look for good median outcomes
  • Kelly Criterion teaches us that if you take more risk, all you do is increase probablity and size of bad outcomes
  • Every trader MUST understand the Kelly Criterion (read Thorp's book)
  • Haghani experiment with bet size with biased coin very telling ... most people (financial professionals) went broke!
  • Every finance professor in the country should have been shocked by the Haghani Experiment (but they didn't care)
  • Things happen that you can't put in your probability model
  • 1% of the time you have no idea what's going to happen -- it's not predictable 
  • Takes significant amount of resources to maintain a Value at Risk model
  • Good non-specialist description of VaR: Financial Risk Management for Dummies (a book he wrote)
  • Kelly Criterion teaches you to design trades with maximum loss in mind given your edge ... gets you in the right ballpark
  • Haghani Experiment proved most people have no idea how to size a bet
  • Professional gamblers he asked all instantly knew the optimal bet size in the Haghani Experiment
  • His website: www.eraider.com (lots of fascinating stuff on there)